apollo-openapi/src/main/java/com/ctrip/framework/apollo/openapi/api/NamespaceOpenApiService.java (3)

29-29: Approve change with suggestions for improvement

The addition of the fillItemDetail parameter aligns with the PR objectives and provides the desired functionality to optionally retrieve item details. However, there are a couple of improvements that could be made:

1. Add documentation for the new fillItemDetail parameter to clarify its purpose and usage.
2. Consider adding a deprecated version of the old method signature to maintain backwards compatibility for existing clients.

Here's a suggested implementation with these improvements:

/**
 * Get namespace information.
 *
 * @param appId The application ID
 * @param env The environment
 * @param clusterName The cluster name
 * @param namespaceName The namespace name
 * @param fillItemDetail Whether to fill item details in the response
 * @return The namespace information
 */
OpenNamespaceDTO getNamespace(String appId, String env, String clusterName, String namespaceName, boolean fillItemDetail);

/**
 * @deprecated Use {@link #getNamespace(String, String, String, String, boolean)} instead.
 */
@Deprecated
default OpenNamespaceDTO getNamespace(String appId, String env, String clusterName, String namespaceName) {
    return getNamespace(appId, env, clusterName, namespaceName, true);
}

This approach provides clear documentation and maintains backwards compatibility.

---

31-31: Approve change with suggestions for improvement

The addition of the fillItemDetail parameter to the getNamespaces method aligns with the PR objectives and provides the desired functionality to optionally retrieve item details for multiple namespaces. However, similar to the getNamespace method, there are a couple of improvements that could be made:

1. Add documentation for the new fillItemDetail parameter to clarify its purpose and usage.
2. Consider adding a deprecated version of the old method signature to maintain backwards compatibility for existing clients.

Here's a suggested implementation with these improvements:

/**
 * Get multiple namespaces information.
 *
 * @param appId The application ID
 * @param env The environment
 * @param clusterName The cluster name
 * @param fillItemDetail Whether to fill item details in the response
 * @return List of namespace information
 */
List<OpenNamespaceDTO> getNamespaces(String appId, String env, String clusterName, boolean fillItemDetail);

/**
 * @deprecated Use {@link #getNamespaces(String, String, String, boolean)} instead.
 */
@Deprecated
default List<OpenNamespaceDTO> getNamespaces(String appId, String env, String clusterName) {
    return getNamespaces(appId, env, clusterName, true);
}

This approach provides clear documentation and maintains backwards compatibility.

---

Line range hint 1-38: Overall feedback on changes

The modifications to the NamespaceOpenApiService interface successfully implement the desired functionality to optionally retrieve item details when fetching namespace information. This aligns well with the PR objectives and addresses the issue described in #5243.

However, to ensure a smooth transition and maintain API usability, consider the following recommendations:

1. Add clear documentation for the new fillItemDetail parameter in both getNamespace and getNamespaces methods.
2. Implement deprecated versions of the old method signatures to maintain backwards compatibility.
3. Update the class-level documentation to mention this new functionality.

These changes will significantly improve the API's usability and ensure a smoother transition for existing clients.

As this change affects a public API, consider updating the API documentation and providing migration guides for users upgrading to this new version. Additionally, it might be beneficial to add examples of how to use these new method signatures in the Apollo documentation.

apollo-openapi/src/test/java/com/ctrip/framework/apollo/openapi/client/service/NamespaceOpenApiServiceTest.java (2)

61-61: Consider adding a test case for fillItemDetail=false.

The test has been updated to use the new method signature with fillItemDetail=true, which is good. However, to ensure comprehensive test coverage, it would be beneficial to add another test case that checks the behavior when fillItemDetail is set to false.

Would you like me to provide an example of how to implement this additional test case?

---

86-86: Consider adding a test case for fillItemDetail=false.

The test has been updated to use the new method signature with fillItemDetail=true, which is good. However, to ensure comprehensive test coverage, it would be beneficial to add another test case that checks the behavior when fillItemDetail is set to false for the getNamespaces method.

Would you like me to provide an example of how to implement this additional test case?

apollo-openapi/src/main/java/com/ctrip/framework/apollo/openapi/client/service/NamespaceOpenApiService.java (3)

Line range hint 44-62: LGTM! Consider adding a deprecated method for backwards compatibility.

The changes to getNamespace method look good and align with the PR objectives. The new fillItemDetail parameter is correctly added and used in the OpenApiPathBuilder.

To ensure better backwards compatibility, consider adding a deprecated version of the method:

@Deprecated
@Override
public OpenNamespaceDTO getNamespace(String appId, String env, String clusterName, String namespaceName) {
    return getNamespace(appId, env, clusterName, namespaceName, true);
}

This will allow existing code to continue working while encouraging migration to the new method signature.

---

Line range hint 73-88: LGTM! Consider adding a deprecated method for backwards compatibility.

The changes to getNamespaces method look good and align with the PR objectives. The new fillItemDetail parameter is correctly added and used in the OpenApiPathBuilder.

To ensure better backwards compatibility, consider adding a deprecated version of the method:

@Deprecated
@Override
public List<OpenNamespaceDTO> getNamespaces(String appId, String env, String clusterName) {
    return getNamespaces(appId, env, clusterName, true);
}

This will allow existing code to continue working while encouraging migration to the new method signature.

---

Incomplete Updates in Related Classes

The NamespaceOpenApiService interface has been successfully updated with the new fillItemDetail parameter. However, the ApolloOpenApiClient class still contains deprecated method calls to getNamespace and getNamespaces that need to be updated to utilize the new parameters.

Please address the following:

• Replace deprecated getNamespace and getNamespaces calls in the ApolloOpenApiClient class with the updated method signatures that include the fillItemDetail parameter.
• Update all existing calls across the codebase to use the new methods to ensure consistency and leverage the improved functionality.
• Consider removing or properly documenting deprecated methods to prevent future confusion and maintain codebase cleanliness.

🔗 Analysis chain

Line range hint 1-145: Overall changes look good. Don't forget to update related classes.

The modifications to getNamespace and getNamespaces methods are well-implemented and align with the PR objectives. The new fillItemDetail parameter allows clients to control whether to retrieve detailed item information, which should improve efficiency as intended.

To ensure consistency across the codebase, please make sure to:

1. Update the NamespaceOpenApiService interface with the new method signatures.
2. Modify the ApolloOpenApiClient class to utilize the new parameter.
3. Update any existing calls to these methods in other parts of the codebase.

You can use the following script to verify these changes:

This script will help ensure that all necessary updates have been made throughout the codebase.

🏁 Scripts executed

The following scripts were executed for the analysis:

Script:

#!/bin/bash
# Description: Verify updates to related classes and usage of new methods

# Check for updates in the interface
echo "Checking NamespaceOpenApiService interface:"
rg --type java "interface NamespaceOpenApiService" -A 10

# Check for updates in ApolloOpenApiClient
echo "Checking ApolloOpenApiClient class:"
rg --type java "class ApolloOpenApiClient" -A 20

# Check for existing calls to getNamespace and getNamespaces
echo "Checking existing calls to getNamespace and getNamespaces:"
rg --type java "getNamespace\(|getNamespaces\("

Length of output: 22305

apollo-openapi/src/main/java/com/ctrip/framework/apollo/openapi/client/ApolloOpenApiClient.java (4)

103-107: LGTM! Consider adding @Deprecated annotation.

The deprecation of the existing getNamespaces method is well-implemented. The comment correctly directs users to the new method, and the implementation ensures backward compatibility.

Consider adding the @Deprecated annotation to complement the Javadoc @deprecated tag:

+  @Deprecated
   @deprecated use {@link ApolloOpenApiClient#getNamespaces(String, String, String, boolean)} instead
   */
  public List<OpenNamespaceDTO> getNamespaces(String appId, String env, String clusterName) {
    return namespaceService.getNamespaces(appId, env, clusterName, true);
  }

---

109-114: LGTM! Consider enhancing the Javadoc.

The new getNamespaces method with the fillItemDetail parameter aligns well with the PR objectives. It provides the desired flexibility in retrieving namespace information.

Consider enhancing the Javadoc to explain the purpose of the fillItemDetail parameter:

   /**
    * Get the namespaces
+   * @param fillItemDetail if true, fill item details for each namespace; if false, only return namespace metadata
    * @since 2.4.0
    */
  public List<OpenNamespaceDTO> getNamespaces(String appId, String env, String clusterName, boolean fillItemDetail) {
    return namespaceService.getNamespaces(appId, env, clusterName, fillItemDetail);
  }

---

136-140: LGTM! Consider adding @Deprecated annotation.

The deprecation of the existing getNamespace method is well-implemented. The comment correctly directs users to the new method, and the implementation ensures backward compatibility.

Consider adding the @Deprecated annotation to complement the Javadoc @deprecated tag:

+  @Deprecated
   @deprecated use {@link ApolloOpenApiClient#getNamespace(String, String, String, String, boolean)} instead
   */
  public OpenNamespaceDTO getNamespace(String appId, String env, String clusterName, String namespaceName) {
    return namespaceService.getNamespace(appId, env, clusterName, namespaceName, true);
  }

---

142-147: LGTM! Consider enhancing the Javadoc.

The new getNamespace method with the fillItemDetail parameter aligns well with the PR objectives. It provides the desired flexibility in retrieving namespace information for a specific namespace.

Consider enhancing the Javadoc to explain the purpose of the fillItemDetail parameter:

   /**
    * Get the namespace
+   * @param fillItemDetail if true, fill item details for the namespace; if false, only return namespace metadata
    * @since 2.4.0
    */
  public OpenNamespaceDTO getNamespace(String appId, String env, String clusterName, String namespaceName, boolean fillItemDetail) {
    return namespaceService.getNamespace(appId, env, clusterName, namespaceName, fillItemDetail);
  }

Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL